Simulation of SO2, NOx and NO2 exposure in the sixties,
seventies and eighties in a retrospective case control study of
lung cancer in the Stockholm region.
Lung cancer incidence is increased in urban areas including Stockholm.
Although smoking is the most important risk factor for lung cancer,
it does not seem to fully explain the excess risk and ambient
air pollution may be of importance.
A simulation project was started called the LUCAS project, a retrospective
study of LUng CAncer in Stockholm county. The SLB·analys part of the
study is to perform simulations of the exposure of sulphur dioxide
and nitrogen oxides to persons who have died in lung cancer. In
April 1997 SLB·analys finished the building of emission databases for
the sixties, seventies and eighties and the simulations from these
databases.
Methods
1000 cases of lung cancer in men aged 40 to 75 diagnosed between
1985 and 1990 were identified in the regional cancer registry.
3000 controls were selected from the general population. Information
on individual exposure was collected with a postal questionnaire,
including questions on dwellings from 1950 and onwards. The addresses
were then transformed into geographical coordinates using the
MAPINFO computer software in conjunction with a regional geographical
database.
It was possible to assign geographical coordinates automatically
for most of the addresses stated in the questionnaires. The address
coordinates for the remaining addresses were assigned semi-automatically
using graphical computer maps. The validity of the geographical
coordinates was assessed by a visual graphical method and by comparison
with another GIS method of assigning coordinates.
Very detailed regional emission databases for 1993 were used as
starting databases. The growing of the urban areas in the Stockholm
region, the expansion of the district heating system and the growth
in the road traffic were then mapped through the sixties, seventies
and eighties.
Emission databases were built for the sixties,seventies and eighties,
describing SO2 and NOx emissions from the main sources - heating
and road traffic. The emission databases were built by using the
AIRVIRO system. The databases describe the average emissions during
the sixties, seventies and eighties. The emissions are described
as point sources, grid sources and line sources.
Dispersion calculations from the emission databases representing
the sixties, seventies and eighties were performed by use of the
Gaussian model in the AIRVIRO system. Calculations were made for
SO2 and NOx as yearly mean values. The NOx concentrations were
then also transformed to NO2 data using relationships from the
measurement databases. The dispersion calculations were performed
in four different resolutions - 2000x2000, 500x500, 200x200 and
100m times 100m calculation grids.
The results from the dispersion calculations were compared with
measured data from the sixties, seventies and eighties for SO2,
and measured data from the eighties for NOx and NO2. Emission
levels were the most uncertain input data to the calculations.
By an iteration of emission and dispersion calculations the differences
between calculated and measured data could be minimized. After
the final dispersion calculations all calculated data at monitoring
stations are in an interval plus minus twenty percent compared
to measured data.
NOx and NO2 were used as indicators of air pollution from road
traffic in the study. Therefore the final dispersion calculations
included only these sources. For main streets in the city centre
the street canyon contribution of NOx and NO2 concentrations were
added to the roof concentrations. These contributions were defined
by dispersing calculations with the AIRVIRO street canyon model.
The SO2 concentration fields were used as indicators for air pollution
from heating.
The air pollution data were then linked to 11000 individual address
coordinates for the relevant time intervals yielding exposure
indices for each of the three air pollution indicators for each
decade.
|
Next page |